Having a new roof installed on your home is a big project that requires homeowners to make a litany of decisions. You’ll not only have to choose the material you want installed (asphalt shingles, slate, or standing seam metal, among others), but also the color of the material and various factors relating to the underlayment and ventilation.
Most homeowners opt for asphalt roofing shingles, but even then, you’ll have to make many other decisions. And the best place to start is by selecting the shingle brand you’d like.
We’ll try to help with this part of the process by sharing nine of the best shingle brands available for your Toledo, Ohio home.
The Best Asphalt Shingle Brands for Your Toledo Home: 9 Great Shingle Options
Choosing roofing shingles can be a daunting feat, given the number of options, styles, and colors on the market. However, we’ll try to simplify things for you and help you select the right shingles by outlining nine of the best roofing shingle brands available!
1. CertainTeed
- Price Range: $ to $$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Presidential Shake and Grand Manor
- Best For: Homeowners looking for a high-quality, long-lasting shingle from a reputable manufacturer.
We’ll start by examining CertainTeed, a well-established manufacturer based outside Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Founded in 1904 as the General Roofing Manufacturing Company, CertainTeed produces a wide range of building and roofing materials, including insulation, drywall, siding, and, of course, roofing shingles.
CertainTeed’s shingle lineup spans from budget-friendly shingle options, like their XT 25 three-tab roofing shingles, to the brand’s mid-range Landmark architectural series, to their high-end Presidential Shake, Carriage House, and Grand Manor lines.
CertainTeed shingles are known for their Class A fire ratings, algae resistance, and multi-layer construction that provides enhanced durability. CertainTeed also offers some of the strongest warranties in the industry. Most of their product lines are backed by at least a 20-year warranty, and some feature a lifetime limited warranty.
2. Owens Corning
- Price Range: $ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Duration and Oakridge
- Best For: Homeowners seeking reliable performance, attractive design options, and strong warranty coverage.
Owens Corning is a bit special because they’re headquartered right in Toledo, Ohio. Known for manufacturing a broad range of building materials, ranging from insulation to roofing products, the company was first established in 1938.
Owens Corning’s roofing lineup includes options at just about every price point imaginable. They offer entry-level Supreme three-tab shingles for those seeking basic protection at a low price, as well as their Oakridge and TruDefinition Duration lines for homeowners seeking architectural styling and enhanced performance. The Duration line features Owens Corning’s proprietary SureNail Technology, which includes a reinforced nailing strip. This strip provides improved installation accuracy and impressive wind resistance.
For homeowners seeking a premium product, Owens Corning offers the Berkshire series, which mimics the look of natural slate, yet costs only a fraction as much.
3. Atlas
- Price Range: $ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: StormMaster Shake and Pinnacle Impact
- Best For: Homeowners who want roofing shingles that provide serious impact resistance and weather durability, while looking good for decades.
Atlas Roofing Corporation is one of the newcomers to the roofing material industry, as they were only founded in 1982. But despite being new, this Meridian, Mississippi brand has grown to become one of the largest roofing manufacturers in the U.S. Over this time, Atlas has built a strong reputation for producing durable, weather-resistant asphalt shingles.
The company offers a wide range of products, from the budget-friendly ProLam shingles to higher-end options such as Pinnacle Impact and StormMaster Shake. These premium shingles are designed to withstand extreme weather and include features like Class 4 impact resistance. Some even have wind ratings up to 150 miles per hour. They also offer cool roof shingles, which are designed to help reflect solar radiation and keep your house cooler.
Many Atlas roofing shingles also incorporate Scotchgard Protector, which helps prevent black streaks caused by algae. This helps keep your shingles looking brand new for longer and increases your home’s curb appeal. Atlas shingles are also available in an array of styles and colors, making it easy to find the perfect match for your home’s decor and style.
4. Malarkey
- Price Range: $$ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Vista AR and Highlander
- Best For: Homeowners seeking performance, durability, and environmentally conscious roofing products.
Based in Portland, Oregon, Malarkey Roofing Products first began manufacturing roofing shingles in 1956, and they’re showing no signs of slowing down. The company serves primarily the western United States, so they aren’t as commonly seen in Toledo, but they remain a viable option for homeowners in Ohio.
Malarkey’s product line includes a range of options, from standard three-tab shingles to higher-performance architectural shingles such as Vista AR, Legacy Scotchgard, and Highlander. They also offer Windsor Scotchgard designer roofing shingles that provide a premium cedar shake appearance and unparalleled weather resistance. The brand also offers the Ecoasis line, which features shingles designed to reflect solar heat. This helps to improve energy efficiency in your home and reduce power bills.
Of special note is Malarkey’s use of rubberized asphalt, which provides increased flexibility, impact resistance, and overall durability. The company also incorporates sustainable practices, using recycled materials like plastic bags and tires in its manufacturing process.
5. GAF
- Price Range: $ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Timberline HDZ and Grand Sequoia
- Best For: Homeowners seeking reliability, performance, and comprehensive warranty options.
One of the oldest and largest roofing manufacturers in the United States, GAF has been in business since 1886. They produce a variety of roofing products, including underlayment, ventilation systems, solar-integrated roofing components, and asphalt shingles.
GAF’s shingles include affordable options like the Marquis WeatherMax and Royal Sovereign three-tab shingles, as well as their incredibly popular Timberline architectural series. The Timberline HDZ and UHDZ shingles are likely the brand’s top-of-the-line products, as they feature LayerLock technology, Class A fire ratings, and built-in algae protection.
GAF also offers an array of designer shingles, including their Grand Canyon, Camelot, and Grand Sequoia lines. All three of these product lines have distinctive profiles and help improve your home’s curb appeal.
6. IKO
- Price Range: $ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Nordic and Crowne Slate
- Best For: Homeowners in cold or storm-prone climates who want a weather-resistant shingle.
IKO is a Canadian-based roofing manufacturer that focuses on producing roofing shingles designed to withstand extremely harsh weather conditions (like the ones that commonly affect Ohio). Founded in 1951, IKO offers a wide range of durable and impact-resistant asphalt shingles that boast impressive wind-resistance ratings.
IKO’s product line includes architectural and designer shingles, including their Nordic, Dynasty, and Crowne Slate product lines. The Nordic premium shingles are engineered with a Class 4 impact resistance rating and designed to withstand wind speeds up to 130 miles per hour. Dynasty premium shingles feature IKO’s ArmourZone technology, which provides a wider nailing area to provide superior wind resistance. The Crowne Slate line offers the appearance of natural slate at a more affordable price point.
IKO also manufactures three-tab roofing shingles for budget-conscious homeowners.
7. Tamko
- Price Range: $ to $$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Heritage Architectural and Titan XT
- Best For: Homeowners seeking dependable roofing materials with solid performance characteristics.
Tamko Building Products is based in Missouri and first opened their doors in 1944. A well-known manufacturer of both residential and commercial roofing materials, Tamko shingles balance performance with affordability. Their product lines tend to emphasize architectural shingle styles and improved weather resistance.
Tamko’s product lineup includes roofing shingles at all ends of the budgetary spectrum. From their affordable Elite Glass-Seal three-tab shingles to their high-end Heritage architectural series, they have something for everyone. They also offer premium Titan XT shingles, which are designed to withstand wind speeds of up to 160 miles per hour.
In addition to asphalt shingles, Tamko is one of the few manufacturers that also offers a metal shingle line, which mimics the look of slate, tile, or wood. Tamko also produces a full suite of roofing accessories, including underlayments and waterproofing products..
8. Pabco
- Price Range: $ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Prestige and Paramount
- Best For: Homeowners looking for something beyond standard architectural shingle styles and colors.
PABCO Roofing Products is a Tacoma, Washington shingle manufacturer that was first established in 1984. Known for producing high-quality asphalt shingles, they primarily distribute their products in the western United States, but they can be special ordered for homeowners who’re set on the brand. Because they’re smaller than many national brands, PABCO offers a streamlined product lineup with an emphasis on durability, aesthetics, and variety.
The company’s entry-level Premier architectural shingles provide reliable performance, yet they’re backed by a limited lifetime warranty. Higher-end options include the Prestige and Paramount Advantage lines, which are thicker to provide greater durability (as well as a “dimensional” appearance, like architectural shingles).
PABCO also offers specialty products such as Radiance, a solar-reflective shingle designed to reduce heat absorption, and their Cascade product line. Cascade roofing shingles are noteworthy for having a diamond-shaped shape that creates an immediate visual impression.
9. BP Canada
- Price Range: $ to $$$
- Our Favorite Product Lines: Mystique 42 and Manoir
- Best For: Homeowners in cold or storm-prone climates who want access to a variety of different aesthetic options.
As their name implies, BP Canada is a Canadian manufacturer, based in LaSalle, Québec. Founded in 1925, BP Canada specializes in products designed to withstand the extreme weather conditions, including snow and high winds.
The company’s product lineup includes several options, such as Mystique 42 laminated architectural shingles, which feature supremely durable, dual-layer construction and a “dimensional” appearance.
The Vangard 42 IR roofing shingles are Class 4 shingles that are engineered for unmatched impact resistance, making them a great choice for homeowners in regions that receive a lot of hail and severe weather. The Manoir line is quite interesting, as it is designed to replicate the look of natural stone. But BP also produces more affordable options, including their Dakota three-tab shingle line.
Many of BP Canada’s roofing shingles incorporate the company’s Weather-Tite Technology, a dual-sealant system designed to prevent wind uplift and reduce the chances of water infiltration.
The Best Roofing Shingle Brands: FAQ
Still have a few questions about the best shingle brands? Still curious about some of the things that distinguish different shingle brands? We’ve rounded up some of the most common questions our customers have to help you out!
Can you change roofing shingle brands when having your roof replaced?
In most cases, yes — if you’re removing all of the existing shingles from your roof and installing a new layer, you can choose any shingle brand you like — just be sure to stick with one that manufactures high-quality shingles!
What are architectural shingles?
Architectural shingles are designed to have a thicker profile than traditional asphalt shingles, which produces an appearance many homeowners love. Architectural shingles do often cost more than traditional asphalt shingles, but they generally increase your home’s curb appeal and property value more.
Do roofing industry professionals like GAF shingles?
By and large, GAF shingles have a good reputation in the roofing industry, and they’re one of the best-regarded shingle brands around. Known for producing high quality roofing products, GAF is definitely a shingle brand that is worthy of consideration.
Which asphalt shingles last the longest?
In general, the longest-lasting roofing shingles are architectural shingles. Architectural shingles are thicker than traditional 3-tab roofing shingles, and they’re generally made from superior materials. However, they also cost more than budget-friendly 3-tab shingles.
What is the highest grade of shingle?
Luxury shingles (also called premium, designer, or architectural shingles) are typically considered the highest-grade asphalt shingles. They’re generally considered the top-of-the-line shingles, and they’re designed to mimic slate or wood shakes. They also offer the best durability, aesthetics, and lifespan of all asphalt products.
Are Owens Corning or GAF shingles better?
Both GAF and Owens Corning shingles are high-quality products, and there are great options made by both brands. With that said, we tend to prefer Owens Corning and recommend the brand’s shingles highly to our customers.
Are Tamko roofing shingles better than GAF?
Both Tamko shingles and GAF roofing shingles are well-made products that tend to perform quite well on Toledo roofs. However, we think that the quality-to-price ratio of Tamko shingles means that they provide excellent value, and they’re especially well-suited for budget-minded homeowners.
What is the number 1 shingle in the U.S.?
It’s difficult to identify the very best shingle brand in the country, but Owens Corning, Atlas, and CertainTeed can all lay a reasonable claim to this title. Just remember that every home, homeowner, and situation is unique, so the important thing is that you select the best shingles for your needs.
Which shingle manufacturer has the best warranty?
It’s hard to make apples-to-apples comparisons of shingle warranties, as they all provide different types of coverages. With that said, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, and Atlas all provide industry-leading warranties, which help homeowners buy with confidence.
What is the most expensive type of shingle?
Slate roofing shingles are by far the most expensive type of shingle available on the market. However, among asphalt shingles, the luxury roofing shingles produced by most premium brands are always their most expensive products.
Which is better: CertainTeed or GAF?
It’s always difficult to identify the best shingle brand, given that every homeowner has different needs. Nevertheless, while GAF shingles are undoubtedly some of the best roofing shingles around, we tend to recommend CertainTeed shingles enthusiastically.
Rely on Frogtown Roofing for New Shingle Installation!
Picking the single brand for your new roof installation or roof replacement is a big decision, but you don’t have to go it alone! The roofing professionals at Frogtown Roofing can help! Whether you would like Owens Corning shingles, GAF shingles, CertainTeed Shingles, or any other brand, we’ll ensure that you get the high-quality shingles you deserve!
Simply head over to our contact page or book an appointment now! One of our roofing professionals will be happy to arrange for an on-site visit and consultation. During the visit, your roofing pro will inspect your current roof condition, ask about your wants and needs, and answer any questions you may have. He or she will then provide some brand recommendations, as well as a complete pricing estimate.
Works Cited
Consumer Reports. Best Roofing Shingles from Consumer Reports’ Tests. Consumer Reports, 9 May 2023, www.consumerreports.org/home-garden/roofing/best-roofing-shingles-from-consumer-reports-tests-a3871500341. Accessed 20 May 2025.
Roofing Insights. Best Roofing Shingles 2024: Annual Shingle Guide. Roofing Insights, 11 Jan. 2024, roofinginsights.com/best-roofing-shingles-2024. Accessed 20 May 2025.
Bob Vila. The Best Roofing Shingles of 2024. BobVila.com, www.bobvila.com/articles/best-roofing-shingles. Accessed 20 May 2025.
