It’s always important to select a high-quality contractor when you need your roof repaired or replaced. Settling for an unprofessional or unreliable organization will just lead to problems that’ll cost you more money in the long run.
But how do you know who you can trust? How do you know which roofing contractors employ actual roofing experts, use premium materials, and provide the kind of customer service you deserve? How do you know which ones will get the job done right the first time?
We’ll try to help below by sharing some tips for figuring out how to separate the best from the rest and picking the ideal roofing contractor for your needs. But we’ll go ahead and share a spoiler: Comparing review counts and ratings is one of the best places to start.
How Do You Pick a Good Roofing Contractor?
Because we’ve been providing high-quality roofing services across the Maumee area for more than 16 years, we know the kinds of things homeowners and property managers should look for when seeking a roofing contractor. Some of the things you’ll want to consider include:
- Licensing and Insurance: Make sure the contractor is licensed to operate in your state and carries both liability and workers’ comp insurance.
- Local Experience: Choose a company with a physical address and a proven track record in your area. Local contractors understand regional weather, codes, and materials.
- Manufacturer Certifications: Contractors certified by top shingle brands (like GAF, Owens Corning, or CertainTeed) often meet higher installation standards.
- Written Estimates: Get at least three detailed quotes that break down materials, labor, warranties, and timelines.
- Warranties: A good roofer will offer both manufacturer and workmanship warranties—and clearly explain what each covers.
- Communication and Professionalism: Reliable roofers return calls, show up on time, and provide clear written proposals.
- Safety: Reputable roofers follow OSHA standards and maintain a safe jobsite.
All of these things are important to consider, but as we mentioned earlier, ratings and reviews provide some of the best information about roofing contractors you may hire.
Reviews not only help demonstrate that the contractor has a proven track record and the necessary experience, but they also give you a chance to hear about their work directly from people who’ve been in your very shoes.
What Reviews Should You Check When Seeking a Roofing Contractor in Maumee?
In the past, it was hard to find things like reviews from previous customers. You were basically limited to learning about the experiences of friends, family, and neighbors. But things have certainly changed! These days, you can find reviews for roofing companies in a variety of different places.
And while they can all be valuable, some are more important to consider than others. We’d typically recommend giving ratings and reviews on the following platforms the most weight:
- Google: The best place to start, Google offers a large volume of reviews from real customers and helps you gauge overall sentiment, recent performance, and the contractor’s scale of operations.
- Better Business Bureau (BBB): The BBB allows you to check the company’s accreditation status, find out how many complaints have been filed against them, and how promptly they’ve responded to issues.
- Angi: Because they often include detailed narratives of what went well (and what didn’t) in individual projects, Angi reviews are helpful for a number of home-service-industry businesses, including roofers.
- Yelp: Yelp is especially useful for reviewing feedback provided by the local community, and it gives you the chance to spot patterns (good or bad) and see how the company engages publicly with customers.
- Facebook: Still one of the most widely used platforms for local business feedback, Facebook is especially helpful for gauging community reputation and seeing how a contractor interacts with customers publicly.
- BirdEye: A reputation management platform that gathers verified customer feedback from multiple sources. BirdEye is useful because it filters out fake reviews and gives a balanced snapshot of customer satisfaction.
- GuildQuality: A third-party survey platform used by many contractors to collect feedback. GuildQuality reviews here tend to be highly credible since the platform verifies that respondents actually hired the company.
- Trustindex: A review aggregator that compiles ratings from major platforms like Google, BBB, and Facebook. It’s a great way to see consistency (or inconsistency) in how a contractor is rated across multiple sources at once.
Relatively few roofing contractors will have reviews on all of these various platforms, but the best candidates for your roofing needs will likely appear on several (and obviously have good ratings and reviews to show for it).
Rating Quantity vs Quality: Which Matters for Roofing Contractors?
It’s pretty easy to understand why you should check ratings and reviews when trying to select a roofing contractor, but it does present a pretty important question: Should you care more about the number of reviews and ratings a roofer has or the average score they’ve attained?
Unfortunately, there’s no easy answer, as they’re both important factors. In practice, you’ll probably want to select a roofer who scores well on both fronts; they should have a fairly large number of reviews and a pretty high average score.
For example, a 5-star rating is obviously impressive, unless that’s based on three reviews. They may very well be a great company, but they certainly haven’t built a lengthy track record. Conversely, tallying 500 reviews is quite an achievement, unless you have an overall 3.5-star rating.
So, rather than opting for either of these extremes, you’d be better off looking for a roofer with 100 to 200 reviews and a 4.3-star rating.
The 10 Roofing Contractors in Maumee, Ohio with the Most Reviews
We’ve sifted through the review sites and business profiles to help dig up the Maumee roofing contractors who’ve collected the most reviews. We’ll share the leading 10 and share a few tidbits about their operation below. Note that because many of these roofing contractors accumulate more reviews every day, they’re not presented in any particular order.
1. Frogtown Roofing Plus
Having served homeowners and property managers in the Maumee, Ohio area for more than 16 years, Frogtown Roofing Plus has accumulated an impressive number of reviews from happy customers.
Collectively, the Frogtown Roofing Plus team has earned 280 Google reviews (for a 4.9-star score) and 36 votes on Facebook (for a 4.9 out of 5 rating). But perhaps most impressively, Frogtown Roofing Plus has 481 reviews on Birdeye — yet another platform on which the team has achieved a 4.9 rating.
Further validating the company’s reputation, this full-service roofing contractor (which provides services ranging from roof replacement to skylight installation to gutter protection) has earned an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau (BBB).
2. Good Guys Roofing
Good Guys Roofing offers roofing, siding, and gutter installation services for commercial and residential customers in Northwest Ohio. Dedicated to “combining small-town values with professional expertise,” the company has racked up 152 Google reviews, 14 Facebook votes, 3 reviews on Yelp, and 1 on HomeAdvisor. Good Guys Roofing has two Ohio offices — one in Maumee and one in Defiance.
3. Roofing Done Rite LLC
Serving both Ohio and Indiana, Roofing Done Rite LLC has accumulated quite a few reviews over its 8-year-long history. This includes 315 Google reviews and 133 Facebook reviews, as well as 3 reviews on Yelp. They also have a pretty robust social media presence, with profiles on YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, and LinkedIn, making it easy for potential customers to learn more about the business.
4. Roof Ohio
Roof Ohio has been serving the Northwest Ohio area since 1997, and they provide a full line of roofing services, as well as window and seamless gutter installation. Based in Swanton, Ohio, this contractor has tallied 295 Google reviews, 12 Facebook reviews, and 4 reviews on Yelp. The Roof Ohio team prides itself on offering a comprehensive warranty that they call one of the “best no-hassle warranties” in the region.
5. Salinas Roofing, Siding, & Exteriors
Though they have only been operating since 2018, Salinas Roofing, Siding, & Exteriors has amassed quite a few reviews, including 432 on Google alone. They also have 18 reviews on Angi, 57 votes on GuildQuality, and 429 votes on Trustindex. Salinas Roofing, Siding, & Exteriors offers an array of home exterior services, ranging from roofing to door installation to siding repairs.
6. Salgau Roofing
With 203 Google reviews, 121 Angi reviews, and 7 Yelp reviews, Salgau Roofing serves both homeowners and commercial property managers across Northwest Ohio. With a 26-year-long history, an A+ rating from the BBB, and a strong social media presence (including profiles on YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, and more), Salgau Roofing makes it easy for potential customers to learn about their business.
7. 4 Guys and a Roof
Although they don’t have the breadth of reviews that some other Maumee-area roofing contractors do, 4 Guys and a Roof has an overwhelmingly positive local reputation. They have 110 Google reviews and 5 reviews on Yelp, as well as an A+ rating from the BBB. This contractor offers both roofing repairs and chimney repair services, and they’ve been in business for 27 years.
8. Integrity Home Exteriors
With a 25-year-long history and 1,546 Google reviews, Integrity Home Exteriors has established a solid reputation in the Maumee area. The outfit also has 12 Yelp reviews and 159 Angi reviews to go along with 18 Glassdoor reviews from current and former employees. Integrity Home Exteriors offers an especially wide assortment of services, including not only roof replacement but also siding, window, and lawn-care services.
9. Freedom Roofing, Windows, and Siding LLC
Based in Woodville, Ohio, Freedom Roofing, Windows, and Siding is an award-winning roofing and exterior contractor that serves the Maumee area. With a history stretching back 13 years, Freedom Roofing, Windows and Siding LLC has earned 324 Google reviews, 40 Facebook ratings, and 7 reviews on Yelp. The business also has an A+ rating from the BBB, further demonstrating its commitment to customer service.
10. Macke Roofing & Home Remodeling
Macke Roofing & Home Remodeling provides roof replacement, siding installation, and storm damage repairs for both residential and commercial clients in the Maumee area. Over the last 27 years, Macke Roofing & Home Remodeling has accumulated 40 Google reviews and 5 Angi reviews, as well as an A+ rating from the BBB. This contractor is available for emergency service 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Frogtown Roofing Plus: The Best Roofing Contractor in Maumee, Ohio
It’s certainly important to check out the ratings and reviews for any roofing contractor you decide to hire in the Maumee, Ohio area. And that includes Frogtown Roofing Plus! Honestly, we’d love for you to check out our ratings, see how well we’ve treated our previous customers, and then leave us a review of your own after we’ve provided the roof repair, inspection, or replacement services you need!
Or, if you’re already convinced Frogtown Roofing Plus is the roofing contractor you are ready to trust, set up your free estimate and onsite visit now!
